Store team leader Garrett and his team welcome you to Pet Supplies Plus Penfield! Garrett has a Sun Conure named Mango, several reptiles, and an Axolotl name Loki. He has been with PSP for four years. Assistant Store Team Leader Courtney has an Australian Shepherd named Willow and a bearded dragon named Gimli. Shift Supervisor Randy has an Alaskan Malamute named Freyja, two leopard geckos, and two cats. Here at Pet Supplies Plus, we regularly host adoption events, community events, and contests! We look forward to seeing you soon!
We offer a self-serve dog wash! We provide the soap, towels, and blowdryer, you provide the dog! (We also take care of the cleanup afterwards!)
Every other Sunday, VIP Pet Care has a vet clinic here in-store. Call for hours.
We have partnered with Big Dogs Big Hearts and Keller's Cats, two different foster organizations based right out of people's homes!
Here at Pet Supplies Plus, we pride ourselves on our wide variety of natural, healthy dog foods. We also carry toys, grooming supplies, collars and leashes, and more!
A time-tested family recipe
Recklessly crunchy dog treats
Canine comfort food
Gourmet dog food & treats
A holistic approach to complete nutrition
Help maintain gut regularity
Complete and balanced pâté recipes
Cracker snacks for dogs
Soft & Savory Treats for Dogs
We carry a wide variety of cat foods (both dry and wet), cat toys, beds, scratching trees, wellness/health items, and more!
Gourmet cat food
A holistic approach to complete nutrition
The Purrrrrfect Way to Treat Your Cat
Family pets aren't always of the fuzzy variety. We also carry items for fish, reptiles, birds, and small animals.
